You built a wall between your companies. Then lent across it.
You set up a second company for a reason. Usually so that if one went wrong, it couldn’t take the other down with it. A wall between them.
Then one month Company A was short and Company B had cash in the bank. Same owner, same banking app, thirty seconds. Nobody decided to make an intercompany loan. It just happened, and then it happened again. Three years later there’s a six-figure line between the two and nobody can say what it’s for.
That line is a hole in the wall. Here’s what comes through it.
If the borrower falls over, the lender’s money can go with it. Your good company is now just another unsecured creditor of your bad one, in the queue with everyone else. If the lender falls over, a liquidator will want that loan back from the other company, in cash. Either way, the trouble you built two companies to contain is now in both.
Nobody wrote anything down. No agreement, no terms, no date it gets repaid. Nobody notices until a bank, a buyer or IRD asks what it is.
And it hides the truth. If one company only survives on money from the other, it isn’t a business. It’s a cost. The loan lets you avoid looking at that.
So when does a loan between them make sense? When it’s deliberate. A set amount, for a reason, written down, with a date it gets paid back.
Most of the time there’s a better way. If one company does work for the other, or carries its staff, its rent or its gear, charge for it. A proper invoice at a fair price, with GST where it applies. Now each set of accounts tells the truth. And if the money is really yours to move, move it as yours: take it out of the first company properly and put it into the second through your current account. Now the second company owes you, not its sister, and the two aren’t tied to each other. That can mean tax on the way out, so do the sums first.
And interest? If both companies have exactly the same owners in the same shares, an interest-free loan between them usually isn’t a tax problem. Once the ownership differs, even a little, a free loan is one lot of shareholders doing the other lot a favour, and IRD can treat the missing interest as a dividend. That’s when interest usually gets charged, at a market rate or the rate IRD sets. It turns on the detail, so ask before the money moves, not after.
So a loan between your companies isn’t a problem in itself. It becomes one when one company goes down and the other doesn’t, or when the two don’t have the same owners.
Two companies are either separate or they aren’t. Decide which, and make the bank transfers match.
Tim Lucas, Chartered Accountant
Got a loan sitting between your companies and no idea how it got that big? Let’s untangle it.
021 277 6778
